This is our first review of a charcoal that is made in Poland, so we thought we'd help you all out with
a map of Poland so you'll know where it came from. This is Vision's high end charcoal,
if you will, as distiguished from the less expensive charcoal it sells in stores like Sams. It was provided to us by
Vision Grills for review, so let's see how it does.
First, we dump the charcoal out on a plastic sheet for sorting. We found a few interesting things
in the charcoal. We found a rock, two of the plastic strips used for making woven plastic fabrics like you see some charcoal
bags made of, and a yellow plastic tie. Needless to say, rocks are normal but plastic is not. Vision needs to tighten
up on their quality control so unwanted items don't get into the charcoal.
When we sorted the pieces by size, we found a somewhat disappointing distribution of sizes. Three quarters of the bag consisted
of small pieces, only 6.5% medium pieces and no truly large pieces. As you can see from the following table, we also found 18%
of the bag was unusable chips and dust:
Large |
0.0 pounds |
0.0% |
Medium |
1.3 pounds |
6.5% |
Small |
15.2 pounds |
75.5% |
Chips/Dust |
3.6 pounds |
18.0% |
|
|
|
Total |
20.1 pounds |
|
|
We asked the manufacturer about this predominance of small pieces and this is what they told us:
"...the carbonization of the charcoal I sent you is the reason for the smaller pieces, it kind of goes
like this. The higher you carbonize a charcoal the smaller the pieces become because as you take water content out of
the charcoal it basically becomes smaller or shrinks. That’s why the size of our bag is so much bigger than any other
20 lb. bag. We have to put more wood in it to equal 20 lbs. because we have most of the water weight out of the
charcoal which makes it burn longer and eliminates sparks and reduces smoke to a minimum. In short we ordered the
charcoal in the small pieces if they were larger they would not be as highly carbonized."
Nonetheless, owners of ceramic cookers would still probably like to see a distribution with more large/medium pieces
and fewer small pieces, not to mention a smaller percentage of the chips and dust which most users don't want.
Fortunately, things get better from here. A lot better. In our chimney starter test, Vision Professional charcoal
only took 2 sheets of newspaper to get going. It just doesn't get much easier to light charcoal than this. During
starting, there were some sparks, but no popping. The smoke during lighting was very mild.
In our maximum temperature test, this charcoal hit 1134° F which is very high compared to other charcoals. In
fact, it's the fourth highest temperature we have ever measured to date. During this test, the fire spread quite
quickly with again, little sparking and no popping. And again, the smoke was mild smelling during the test.
Next, on to our burn time test. Vision Professional set a new record as far as out testing goes to date. It just
burned and burned and burned. And finally in our ash production test, this charcoal produced an amount of ash that
was very low compared to other charcoals we have tested.
So, as you can see from our key performance indicators, Vision Professional Lump Charcoal got 5 stars in every
category except for the amount of chips and dust. The poor size distribution, large quantity of chips and dust, and
the presence of the plastic that we found
in the bag means we can only give it our Recommended rating. Vision Professional Lump Charcoal is sold at
pool and spa outlets.