It was in 2005 that we last reviewed Weekend Warrior Blend from the good folks at Wicked Good Charcoal so when
we spied a bag at our local Ace Hardware, we thought it was time to give it another look. Not only is the
passage of time justification for a re-review, but also back in 2005 we didn't conduct all the tests that we
do now. So in addition to bringing our review up to date, we'll have more information on which to form our
conclusion.
Like the 2005 Weekend Warrior Blend, today's version is made from a blend of South American hardwoods and
comes to us from Brazil. Our thoughtfully-provided map showing the location of Brazil is to the right.
So, let's see how Weekend Warrior Blend charcoal does now in 2021!
The first thing we do is dump the bag out onto the ground in order to inspect the contents for anything
in the charcoal which doesn't belong, like insulation or metal, and then sort the bag into large, medium
and small pieces, as well as chips and dust. We found absolutely nothing in the bag except charcoal and
the following table shows the distribution of the different sizes:
Large |
10.3 pounds |
51.8% |
Medium |
5.3 pounds |
26.6% |
Small |
3.1 pounds |
15.6% |
Chips/Dust |
1.2 pounds |
6.0% |
|
|
|
Total |
19.9 pounds |
|
|
The first thing that should catch your eye is the exceptionally large percentage of large pieces.
This photo shows the bag sorted by sizes.
Nearly 79% of the bag consisted of large and medium pieces. Personally, a number of the pieces
were too large for our liking, but we know there are those of you out there who want monster logs
and this bag surely provided some. The 6.0% of chips and dust is Low compared to other brands
of lump charcoal.
Incidentally, you may notice that the bag was underweight by a tenth of a pound, or 1.6 ounces. As you can see in
this photo,
the bag was torn and had been taped back together by the store.
The next thing we do is test how hard or easy it is to light the charcoal by counting how many sheets of newpaper
it takes to get a good fire started in a standard chimney starter. Weekend Warrior took four sheets to start which is
Average compared to other charcoals. The smell of the charcoal during lighting was quite mild and pleasant. Also, there
was very little sparking or popping while the charcoal was lighting.
From there, we dump the lit charcoal into a cooker, add some more and then record the highest temperature
that the charcoal burns at. In this case, Weekend Warrior burned at 889°F, which is High compared to other
brands. Again, there was very little sparking or popping while the charcoal was burning away. The fire was
moderately slow to spread in the cooker.
Next, in our burn time test Weekend Warrior burned a very long time which was Very High compared to other brands.
It was just outside the top 10 longest burning charcoals in our testing. Lighting with a MAP/Pro torch produced
some moderate sparking and popping, and remember, whenever using a torch of any kind to light lump charcoal,
exercise caution.
And finally, the amount of ash produced by Weekend Warrior lump charcoal was Very Low compared to other brands.
So in summary, Weekend Warrior charcoal has a great size distribution, is average when it comes to lighting,
burns very hot for a very very long time, and produces very little ash. Weekend Warrior lump charcoal from
Wicked Good Charcoal earns our Highly Recommended rating.